THE NEW WHO
CNS TUMOR CLASSIFICATION
James G. Smirniotopoulos, M.D.
Professor of Radiology and Neurology
Chairman, Department of Radiology and Nuclear Medicine
Uniformed Services University of the Health Sciences
Bethesda, MD
USA
and
The Armed Forces Institute of Pathology
Washington, DC
Acknowledgments
PLEASE READ this DISCLAIMER
The opinions expressed herein are those of the author(s), and are not necessarily representative of the Uniformed Services University of the Health Sciences (USUHS), the Department of Defense (DOD); or, the World Health Organization (WHO). Medicine is a constantly changing field, and medical information is subject to correction and revision. The reader is entirely responsible for verifying the accuracy and relevance of the information contained herein.
Last Revision: Friday, May 30, 1997 5:36:16 PM
This lecture was converted to hypertext from an actual slide presentation. The text slides as well as "thumbnail" miniatures of the radiologic and pathologic images have been loaded into this single HTML document. (If this is too slow for you, please try the lecture without the thumbnails.) The individual text slides are separated by the horizontal bars. The radiologic and pathologic images are indicated by the "thumbnail" miniatures, and a full-size image (usually with a caption) can be viewed by clicking on the thumbnail button. After viewing each image hit your browser's "back" button to return to the main text presentation. When multiple images are used with a single text slide, hit the thumbnail buttons as you would read a book (Left to Right, Top to Bottom). If you feel inclined to leave the lecture, simply hit your browser's "back" button from the lecture text, to return to the other teaching programs. This is a prototype sample, and we are interested in your comments.
Enjoy!
TUMOR GRADING
- PATHOLOGIST
- RADIOLOGIST
- NEUROSURGEON
- Use the CUSA ("suckable")
- Hard or Firm tumor ("non-suckable")
- HISTOLOGIC MALIGNANCY
- BIOLOGIC MALIGNANCY
- CLINICAL MALIGNANCY
HISTOLOGIC MALIGNANCY
Graded by microscopic features of:
- CELLULAR ATYPIA
- MITOSES (Mitotic Index)
- INFILTRATION (lack of margination or encapsulation)
- NECROSIS (sign of uncontrolled growth)
- VASCULAR CHANGES (tumor neovascularity)
GLIOMA (ASTROCYTOMA)
GRADING SYSTEM:
(after Kernohan and Sayre)
- GRADE I - "BENIGN" or "Low-Grade"
- GRADE II - " "
- GRADE III - ANAPLASTIC, cellular atypia, etc.
- GRADE IV- MALIGNANT, NECROSIS !, Vascularity, Mitoses
GLIOBLASTOMA MULTIFORME
NOTE: Numerous modifications exist, most into three grades,
eg.: Low Grade (Benign), Anaplastic, and GBM (w/ NECROSIS).
HIGH-GRADE ASTROCYTOMAS
MEDIAN SURVIVAL:
- ANAPLASTIC (Grade 3/4) - 28Mos.
- GBM (Grade 4/4, has NECROSIS) - 8 Mos.
ASTROCYTOMA
Five Year Survival
BIOLOGIC MALIGNANCY:
- RAPID GROWTH
- HEMORRHAGE, NECROSIS
- LOCAL EXTENSION
- HEMATOGENOUS DISSEMINATION
CNS NEOPLASM
Prognostic Factors
WHO Classification
- Defines Histologic Subtypes
- Grades Biologic Potential
- Allows International Cooperation
THE NEW WHO
- Biological Potential
- Ascending Scale of Aggression
I - IV
BIOLOGIC CORRELATION
- Low Grade Tumor
- Long-Term Survival
- Stable History (No Progression)
ASTROCYTIC NEOPLASMS
WHO Classification
DIFFUSELY INFILTRATING ASTROCYTOMA
- Astrocytoma (Diffuse, fibrillary, protoplasmic, or gemistocytic astrocytes)
- Anaplastic Astrocytoma (AA)
- Glioblastoma Multiforme (GBM, Giant Cell GBM, Gliosarcoma)
Circumscribed Astrocytoma
- Pilocytic Astrocytoma (Juvenile - JPA)
- Subependymal Giant Cell Astrocytoma
- Superficial Cerebral Astrocytoma (SGCA, the intraventricular tumor of Tuberous Sclerosis)
- Pleomorphic Xanthoastrocytoma (PXA)
WHO GRADING
| GRADE 1 |
JPA |
SGCA |
GANGLIOGLIOMA |
MENINGIOMA |
| GRADE 2 |
PXA |
HEMANGIOPERICYTOMA (HPC) |
|
|
| GRADE 3 |
PXA |
ANAPLASTIC ASTROCYTOMA |
HPC |
|
| GRADE 4 |
GLIOBLASTOMA MULTIFORME (GBM) |
|
|
|
The New WHO
Classification of Brain Tumors
"BENIGN" ASTROCYTOMA
Two types:
- Low grade ("benign")
Diffuse (Adults, cerebral hermisphere and brainstem)
- Low grade "special"
Circumscribed (Children, characteristic location/morphology)
PATTERN ANALYSIS
Neoplasm
ASTROCYTOMA:
Circumscribed
- "Special" astrocytomas, Astrocytoma of Young
- Well circumscribed (yet, no capsule)
- Various Locations (often characteristic)
- Do NOT change grade (except PXA)
- Do NOT spread along WM
- Constellation of findings correlates w/ Histology
PILOCYTIC ASTROCYTOMA
Synonyms: Cystic Cerebellar Astrocytoma, Juvenile Pilocytic Astrocytoma
("PA" or "JPA")
PILOCYTIC ASTROCYTOMA
- Synonyms: Polar Spongioblastoma, Cystic Cerebellar Astrocytoma
- Cell of Origin: Astrocyte (bi-polar, hairlike)
- Associations: in ON (optic nerve) w/ NF-1
- Incidence: 3-6% of ALL Cranial, 32% of Child
- Age: 5-15 (Zulch 3-7)
- Sex: Slight F (11/9)
- Location: Cerebellum, Chiasm/Hypothal, Optic Nerve, Cerebral hemisphere, Cx spinal cord
- Treatment: Surgery, patience (radiation and chemotherapy uncommon)
- Prognosis: 77% at 5 yrs., many patients can be surgically cured
PILOCYTIC ASTROCYTOMA
Radiology
- Cerebellum, Diencephalon
- Majority have significant "cyst"
- "Cyst and Mural Nodule" appearnce is "Classic"
- part of lining does NOT enhance
- Nodule may be heterogeneous
- Exceptional purely solid
- Nodule NOT hyperdense
- Calcification in 5-25%
Image Page 1
PATHOLOGY
- Biphasic pattern
- dense pilocytic glia
- Rosenthal fibers
- loose microcystic areas
- No necrosis
- Low grade
- Abnormal capillaries
allow enhancement, fluid
Image Page 2
GRADING GLIOMAS
51 PILOCYTIC
| |
KERNOHAN |
MAYO-ST. ANNE |
| 1 |
26% |
2% |
| 2 |
69% |
55% |
| 3 |
6% |
35% |
| 4 |
0% |
8% |
ASTROCYTOMA
Five Year Survival

Image Page 3
PILOCYTIC ASTROCYTOMA
Image Page 4
| Pilocytic Astrocytoma |
Hemangioblastoma |
| Enhance |
Enhance |
| Cyst w/Nodule |
Solid<->Cystic |
| Hypodense |
Hyperdense |
| Calcification |
Never |
| NOT Vascular |
Hypervascular Flow Voids |
| Nodule Varies |
Nodule "SubPial" |
PILOCYTIC ASTROCYTOMA
(Juvenile Pilocytic)
- Childhood, Young Adults
- Benign, no mitosis/necrosis
- Circumscribed - Enhancing
- Cyst Formation, Mural Nodule
- Cerebellum and Diencephalon
(Optic tracts, Hypothalmus)
WHO GRADE I
- Circumscribed Astrocytoma
- JPA (Pilocytic)
- SGCA (Subependymal)
- Ganglioglioma
- Meningioma
CIRCUMSCRIBED vs DIFFUSE
ASTROCYTOMAS
- "SPECIAL" ASTROCYTOMA
Circumscribed Growth:
- Pilocytic
- Subependymal Giant Cell
- Pleomorphic Xantho.-
PLEOMORPHIC
XANTHOASTROCYTOMA
- Recently Described, Rare Variant of Astrocytoma
- Arises from Subpial Astrocytes
- Affects Superficial Cerebral Cortex and Meninges
- Temporal >Frontal > Parietal
PLEOMORPHIC
XANTHOASTROCYTOMA
- IMAGING:
CT APPEARANCE:
- Well-Circumscribed Hypodense or Cystic Mass
- Often Isodense Solid Nodule That Intensely Enhances
- May Mimic Juvenile Pilocytic Astrocytoma
- Calcifications Rare
Image Page 5
PLEOMORPHIC
XANTHOASTROCYTOMA
MR APPEARANCE:
- Well-Circumscribed Mass of Variable Size
- Superficial Cortical Location
- T1: Low/Mixed Signal,
- T2: High/Mixed Signal
- Often with Cystic Component
- Solid Portion Intensely Enhances
- Adjacent Meninges May Enhance (Tail)
- Little or No Mass Effect
Image Page 6
ASTROCYTOMAS
- "ORDINARY" ASTROCYTOMA
Diffusely Infiltrate Brain:
- Fibrillary
- Protoplasmic
- Gemistocytic
PATTERN ANALYSIS
Neoplasm
| KERNOHAN |
1 |
2 |
3 |
4 |
| ANAPLASIA |
0 |
Min |
>1/2 |
Marked |
| CELLULARITY |
Mild |
Mild |
Inc |
Marked |
| MITOSIS |
0 |
0 |
Plus |
Marked |
| ENDOTHELIAL |
Min |
Min |
|
Marked |
| NECROSIS |
0 |
0 |
|
Marked |
| TRANSITION |
Broad |
|
|
Sharp |
| ST. ANNE MAYO |
1 |
2 |
3 |
4 |
| ATYPIA |
|
|
|
|
| MITOSES |
|
|
|
|
| ENDOTHELIAL |
|
|
|
|
| NECROSIS |
|
|
|
|
| TOTAL |
0 |
1 |
2 |
3-4 |
ASTROCYTOMA:
DIFFUSE
(Fibrillary, protoplasmic, etc.)
"Adult type" or "Hemispheric" Astrocytoma
Diffusely infiltrate brain, along WM tracts
Continuum, from low-grade to high-grade
Chromosomes 17 => 9 => 10
Progress in Histology over time, changing from Gr 1-2 => Gr3 => Gr 4 (GBM)
Imaging correlates with histology
Image Page 7
ASTROCYTOMA
Radiologic Grading
- TYPE 1 - (Benign, Grade 1-2)
- Homogeneous
- No Enhancement, No Edema
- TYPE 2 - (Anaplastic - Grade 3)
- Variable Enhancement, Edema
- TYPE 3 - (Glioblastoma - Grade 4)
- Heterogeneous (Necrosis, Blood)
- Ring Enhancement, Edema
BENIGN ASTROCYTOMA:
- YOUNGER PATIENT
- CHILDHOOD
- Young Adults (20's - 40's)
- NL VESSELS (NO NEOVASCULARITY)
- BBB INTACT
- NO EDEMA
- NO ENHANCEMENT
- NO TUMOR VESSELS
Benign - Diffuse
HOMOGENEOUS
- NO NECROSIS
- NO HEMORRHAGE
- INCREASED WATER
DARK on CT/T1W and BRIGHT on T2W
- MICROCYST >>> MACROCYST
(macrocysts occur in JPA, etc.)
Image Page 8
MODES OF SPREAD
1. Natural passages
2. Along surfaces
3. Along tracts
4. Across the meninges
SPREAD ALONG TRACTS:
- CORONA RADIATA
- PEDUNCLES
- CORPUS CALLOSUM
- ANTERIOR COMMISURE
- ARCUATE FIBRES
Image Page 9
"MALIGNANT"ASTROCYTOMA:
- Older patient
- 40's and up
- exceptions (PNET)
- Abnl. Vessels (neovascularity)
- BBB abnormality
- vasogenic edema
- contrast enhancement
- irregular vessels, shunting, etc.
- HETEROGENEOUS
- hemorrhage (old/new)
- tumor necrosis
- tumor itself
Image Page 10
GBM
- LOW DENSITY CENTER
- ENHANCING RIM
- hypercellular, fleshy neoplasm
- greatest neovascularity
- CORONA OF "EDEMA" (low density, dark T1W/bright T2W)
- "edematous" white matter
- areas of neoplastic infiltration
Image Page 11
GLIOBLASTOMA MULTIFORME
(Malignant Astrocytoma)
- Adults over 40 yrs.
- Malignant with mitoses, neovascularity
- Discrete ring-enhancing lesion
- Central necrosis, vasogenic edema
- Cerebral hemispheres
(cross the corpus callosum)
GLIAL TUMORS
MR Grading*
| Low Grade (1-2) |
High Grade (3-4) |
| Homogeneous |
Heterogeneous |
| Well defined |
Poorly Defined |
| Min. Mass |
More Mass |
| Min. Edema |
Vasogenic Edema |
| No blood |
Hemosiderin |
*Radiology (1990) 174: 411-415
COMPARISON of GRADING SYSTEMS
Sem Rad Onc (1991); 1: 2-9
NEUROEPITHELIAL TUMORS
WHO Classification
- Astrocytic
- Oligodendroglial
- Ependymal
- Choroid Plexus Tumors
- Neuronal
- Neuronal Mixed w/ Glial
- Pineal
- Embryonal (PNET)
NEOPLASMS OF THE MENINGES
WHO Classification
- MENINGIOMA:
- Meningioma (typical)
- Atypical Meningioma
- Anaplastic (Malignant) Meningioma
- MESENCHYMAL (non-meningothelial)
- Primary MELANOCYTIC Lesions
- UNCERTAIN Origin
- Hemangiopericytoma
- Hemangioblastoma
MENINGEAL TUMORS
WHO Grades
| TYPE |
GRADE |
| MENINGIOMA |
I |
| ATYPICAL MENINGIOMA |
II |
| PAPILLARY MENINGIOMA |
III |
| HEMANGIOPERICYTOMA |
II-III |
| ANAPLASTIC MENINGIOMA |
III |
MENINGIOMA
"Malignant Meningioma"
- Hemangio-Peri-Cytoma (HPC)
- Malignant Fibrous Histiocytoma (MFH)
- Papillary Meningioma
- "Benign" Metastasizing Meningioma
HEMANGIOPERICYTOMA
(HPC)
- Narrow dural base
("Mushrooming")
- No Hyperostosis, No Calcification
- Lobulated (not hemispheric)
- Internal Signal Voids (on MRI)
- Hypervascular on Angio
Image Page 12
DYSEMBRYOPLASTIC
NEUROEPITHELIAL TUMOR (DNT)
- IMAGING:
- MR APPEARANCE
- Focal cortical mass, usually temporal lobe
- Hypointense on T1
- Hyperintense on T2
- Multinodular
- Microcystic
- Megagyric - may cause bony erosion
- Ocassional Enhancement
DYSEMBRYOPLASTIC
NEUROEPITHELIAL TUMOR (DNT)
- IMAGING:
- CT APPEARANCE
- Hypodense Mass
- No Edema
- Rare Calcification
- Calvarial Erosion
- CT Normal in 10%
Image Page 13
The New WHO
Classification of
Brain Tumors
THE NEW WHO
- Ascending Scale of Aggression
I - IV
CORRELATION
- Low Grade
- Long-Term Survival
- Stable Histology
WHO GRADE I
- Circumscribed Astrocytoma
- JPA (Pilocytic)
- SGCA (Subependymal)
- Ganglioglioma
- Meningioma

Return to USUHS Radiology Home Page